top of page

Mastering Piercing Jewelry Selection: Your Guide to Choosing the Perfect Piece

Updated: Mar 29

Opal prong nipple ring, Tourmalinated Quartz earring end, and a gold seam ring with a crescent moon charm – a captivating ensemble of unique and stylish body jewelry pieces
Opal prong nipple ring, Tourmalited Quartz earring end, and a gold seam ring with a crecent moon charm

Body piercing is more than just an art form; it's a powerful means of self-expression. Whether you're new to piercing or adding to your collection, selecting the perfect jewelry for your piercing is a crucial step. The right piece not only enhances your style but also ensures comfort and safety. In this guide, we'll explore essential factors to consider when choosing jewelry for your piercing.

Understanding Piercing Jewelry Selection

One of the first things to consider when choosing body jewelry is the material. The material should be safe for your body, durable, and free from allergens. Here are some popular materials for body jewelry:

  • 14k Gold: Known for its elegance and hypoallergenic properties, 14k Gold is an excellent choice for body jewelry. It's available in various colors, including yellow, white, and rose gold, allowing you to match your style.

  • Titanium: Titanium is another hypoallergenic option that's lightweight and resistant to corrosion. It's an ideal choice for sensitive skin and is used by default for most flatbacks.

  • Surgical Steel: Surgical steel is known for its durability and resistance to corrosion. It's widely used in body jewelry and is generally safe for most individuals.

  • Niobium: Niobium is a biocompatible metal that's often used for body jewelry. It's available in various colors and is suitable for people with metal sensitivities.

Avoid jewelry made from materials like nickel or low-quality alloys, as they can cause skin irritation and allergic reactions.

Size and Style

The size and style of your jewelry should complement your piercing and personal taste. Here are some considerations for different types of piercings:

  • Ear Piercings: For earlobe piercings, studs and hoops in various sizes and designs are popular choices. Cartilage piercings can accommodate a variety of studs or rings when the piercing is fully healed.

  • Nose Piercings: Nose studs and rings come in different styles and sizes. Choose a size and style that suits your facial features and vibe.

  • Lip Piercings: Labret studs, captive bead rings, and circular barbells are common choices. Ensure the length and diameter fit your piercing comfortably.

  • Belly Button Piercings: Belly button rings, including curved barbells, offer a range of options. Consider your anatomy and style when selecting.

  • Eyebrow and Facial Piercings: Curved barbells, captive bead rings, and straight barbells are suitable choices. Ensure the jewelry sits comfortably and complements your facial features.

Gemstones and Decorations

Many people choose jewelry with gemstones or decorative elements to enhance their style. When selecting gemstone jewelry, consider the following:

  • Gemstone Type: Choose gemstones that resonate with you or hold personal significance. Common choices include diamonds, sapphires, opals, and birthstones.

  • Setting: The setting style can vary, from prong-set gems to bezel-set stones. Ensure the setting is secure and won't catch on clothing or hair.

  • Gemstone Size: The size of the gemstone should be proportionate to your piercing. Larger stones can make a statement, while smaller ones offer a subtle sparkle.

  • Quality: Consider the quality of the gemstone, including its cut, clarity, and color. Higher-quality gemstones tend to have more brilliance and vibrancy.

Comfort and Fit

Comfort is paramount when choosing jewelry for your piercing. The jewelry should fit snugly without causing irritation or pressure. Factors to consider include:

  • Gauge Size: The gauge size should match your piercing's size. Using the wrong gauge can lead to discomfort and complications.

  • Length and Diameter: Ensure the jewelry's length and diameter are appropriate for your specific piercing. It should not be too short, causing tightness, or too long, leading to snagging or discomfort.

  • Closure Mechanism: Depending on the type of jewelry (e.g., hoops, rings), consider the closure mechanism. It should be secure and easy to open and close.

Consult a Professional

If you're unsure about which jewelry to choose, don't hesitate to consult a professional piercer. They can assess your piercing, recommend suitable jewelry options, and ensure a safe and comfortable fit. Professional piercers have the expertise to guide you in selecting the perfect jewelry that aligns with your style and piercing type.


Choosing the perfect jewelry for your piercing is a personal and empowering experience. By considering factors such as material, size, style, gemstones, and comfort, you can select jewelry that not only complements your piercing but also reflects your unique style and personality. Remember to prioritize safety and quality to ensure a comfortable and stunning look that lasts.

At Thistle Piercing & Fine Jewelry, we offer a wide selection of high-quality body jewelry, including 14k Gold, titanium, and unique gemstone pieces. Our experienced piercers can assist you in choosing the perfect jewelry for your piercing, providing both style and safety. Visit our shop in Salem to explore our collection and receive professional guidance on your piercing journey.

You can find more information at and be sure to also check out our inspiration gallery as well as The Association of Professional Piercers Instagram.

71 views0 comments


bottom of page